Zelda had years of development and only used the Wii controls to slightly enhance a refined traditional experience. Virtually every other notable Wii game revolves entirely around its own control scheme, hence in almost every case it's a love/hate thing depending on whether or not you're satisfied with how the controller is used. It's probably always going to be like this with Wii titles.
I would, but I'm part of that Sad Cries category. I'll get a Wii eventually, but it probably won't be for awhile since I don't have a lot of cash at the moment and am too lazy to do my taxes. Still have TP sitting on my shelf though.
I lack a Wii. Though reading some impressions of Super Paper Mario and this game makes me wish I had one. About Twilight Princess, I'm still on the fence whether I should get the GCN version now or wait 'til I get a Wii and obtain the Wii version. I'm a bit leaning towards the GCN version because I need my new Zelda fix so much, however the Wii controls somewhat interest me and the fact that it supports widescreen is also a plus.
Oh, does TP GCN supports 480p or is that in the Wii version only?
Also, TP's Wii controls certainly don't make or break the game. Heck, I ended up even turning off the pointing for shooting arrows. If you're planning on getting a Wii already, I'd just go that route, but otherwise there's not much you'd miss by playing on the Cube.
I declared defeat and decided not to try to get one until my birthday (May 19th. I expect a card from you now), where I'll either get it as a present, or will be working agian and can afford to get one without blowing the semester's spending money and/or album funding.